"They aren't nowadays," said Battle. "Shall we see No. 1? No, I think we'll have Miss Aldin next, and get an outside angle on this matrimonial business."
Mary Aldin came in composedly and sat down. Beneath her outward calmness her eyes looked worried.
She answered Leach's questions clearly enough, confirming Nevile's account of the evening. She had come up to bed about ten o'clock.
"Mr. Strange was then with Lady Tressilian?" "Yes, I could hear them talking." "Talking, Miss Aldin, or quarrelling?"
She flushed, but answered quietly: "Lady Tressilian, you know, was fond of discussion. She often sounded acrimonious when she was really nothing of the kind. Also, she was inclined to be autocratic and to domineer over people - and a man doesn't take that kind of thing as easily as a woman does."
"As you do, perhaps," thought Battle.
He looked at her intelligent face. It was she who broke the silence.
"I don't want to be stupid - but it really seems to me incredible, quite incredible, that you should suspect one of the people in this house. Why shouldn't it be an outsider?"
"For several reasons, Miss Aldin. For one thing, nothing was taken and no entry was forced. I needn't remind you of the geography of your own house and grounds, but just bear this in mind. On the west is a sheer cliff down to the sea; to the south are a couple of terraces with a wall and a drop to the sea, on the east the garden slopes down almost to the shore, but it is surrounded by a high wall. The only ways out are a small door leading through on to the road, which was found bolted inside as usual this morning, and the main door to the house, which is set on the road. I'm not saying no one could climb that wall, nor that they could not have got in by using a spare key to the front door or even a skeleton key - but I'm saying that as far as I can see no one did anything of the sort. Whoever committed this crime knew that Barrett took senna pod decoction every night, and doped it - that means someone in the house. The niblick was taken from the cupboard under the stairs. It wasn't an outsider, Miss Aldin."
"It wasn't Nevile! I'm sure it wasn't Nevile!"
"Why are you so sure?"
She raised her hands hopelessly.
"It just isn't like him - that's why! He wouldn't kill a defenceless old woman in bed - Nevile!"
"It doesn't seem very likely," said Battle reasonably, "but you'd be surprised at the things people do when they've got a good enough reason. Mr. Strange may have wanted money very badly."
"I'm sure he didn't. He's not an extravagant person - he never has been." "No, but his wife is."
"Kay? Yes, perhaps - but, oh, it's too ridiculous. I'm sure the last thing Nevile has been thinking of lately is money."
Superintendent Battle coughed.
"Kay told you, I suppose? Yes, it really has been rather difficult. Still, it's nothing to do with this dreadful business."
"Probably not, but all the same, I'd like to hear your version of the affair, Miss Aldin."
Mary said slowly: "Well, as I say, it has created a difficult - situation. Whosoever's idea it was to begin with -"
He interrupted her deftly.
"I understood it was Mr. Nevile Strange's idea?"
"He said it was."
"But you yourself didn't think so?"
"I - no - it isn't like Nevile somehow. I've had a feeling all along that somebody else put the idea into his head."
"Mrs. Audrey Strange, perhaps?"
"It seems incredible that Audrey should do such a thing."
"Then who else could it have been?"
Mary raised her shoulders helplessly.
"I don't know. It's just - queer."
"Queer," said Battle thoughtfully. "That's what I feel about this case. It's queer."
"Everything's been queer. There's been a feeling -I can't describe it. Something in the air. A menace."
"Everybody strung up and on edge?"
"Yes, just that ... We've all suffered from it. Even Mr. Latimer -" She stopped.
"I was just coming to Mr. Latimer. What can you tell me, Miss Aldin, about Mr. Latimer? Who is Mr. Latimer?"
"Well, really, I don't know much about him. He's a friend of Kay's."
"He's Mrs. Strange's friend. Known each other a long time?"
"Yes, she knew him before her marriage."
"Mr. Strange like him?"
"Quite well, I believe."
"No - trouble, there?"
Battle put it delicately. Mary replied at once and emphatically: "Certainly not!"
"Did Lady Tressilian like Mr. Latimer?"
"Not very much."
Battle took warning from the aloof tone of her voice and changed the subject.
"This maid, now, Jane Barren, she has been with Lady Tressilian a long time? You consider her trustworthy?"
"Oh, absolutely. She was devoted to Lady Tressilian." Battle leaned back in his chair.
"In fact you wouldn't consider for a moment the possibility that Barrett hit Lady Tressilian over the head and then doped herself to avoid being suspected?"
"Of course not. Why on earth should she?"
"She gets a legacy, you know."
"So do I," said Mary Aldin. She looked at him steadily.
"Yes," said Battle. "So do you. Do you know how much?"
"Mr. Trelawny has just arrived. He told me."
"You didn't know about it beforehand?"
"No. I certainly assumed, from what Lady Tressilian occasionally let fall, that she had left me something. I have very little of my own, you know. Not enough to live on without getting work of some kind. I thought that Lady Tressilian would leave me at least a hundred a year - but she has some cousins, and I did not at all know how she proposed to leave that money which was hers to dispose of. I knew, of course, that Sir Matthew's estate went to Nevile and Audrey."
"So she didn't know what Lady Tressilian was leaving her," Leach said when Mary Aldin had been dismissed.
"At least, that's what she says."
"That's what she says," agreed Battle. "And now for Bluebeard's first wife."
VII
Audrey was wearing a pale grey flannel coat and skirt. In it she looked so pale and ghostlike that Battle was reminded of Kay's words, "A grey ghost creeping about the house."
She answered his questions simply and without any signs of emotion.
Yes, she had gone to bed at ten o'clock, the same time as Miss Aldin. She had heard nothing during the night.
"You'll excuse me butting into your private affairs," said Battle, "but will you explain just how it comes about that you are here in the house?"
"I always come to stay at this time. This year, my - my late husband wanted to come at the same time and asked me if I would mind."
"It was his suggestion?"
"Oh, yes."
"Not yours?"
"Oh, no."
"But you agreed?"
"Yes, I agreed ... I didn't feel - that I could very well refuse."
"Why not, Mrs. Strange?"
But she was vague.
"One doesn't like to be disobliging."
"You were the injured party?"
"I beg your pardon?"
"It was you who divorced your husband?"
"Yes."
"Do you - excuse me - feel any rancour against him?"
"No- not at all." 178
"You have a very forgiving nature, Mrs. Strange."
She did not answer. He tried silence - but Audrey was not Kay, to be thus goaded into speech. She could remain silent without any hint of uneasiness. Battle acknowledged himself beaten.
"You are sure it was not your idea - this meeting?"
"Quite sure."
"You are on friendly terms with I-he present Mrs. Strange?"
"I don't think she likes me very much."
"Do you like her?"
"Yes. I think she is very beautiful."
"Well - thank you -I think that is all."
She got up and walked towards the door. Then she hesitated and came back.
"I would just like to say -" She spoke nervously and quickly. "You think Nevile did this - that he killed her because of the money. I'm quite sure that isn't so. Nevile has never cared much about money. I do know that. I was married to him for eight years, you know. I just can't see him killing anyone like that for money - it -it - isn't Nevile. I know my saying so isn't of any value as evidence - but I do wish you would believe it."
She turned and hurried out of the room.
"And what do you make of her?" asked Leach. "I've never seen anyone so - so devoid of emotion."
"She didn't show any," said Battle. "But it's there. Some very strong emotion. And I don't know what it is ..."
VIII
Thomas Royde came last. He sat, solemn and stiff, blinking a little like an owl.
He was home from Malaya - first time for eight years. Had been in the habit of staying at Gull's Point ever since he was a boy. Mrs. Audrey Strange was a distant cousin - and had been brought up by his family from the age of nine. On the preceding night he had gone to bed just before eleven. Yes, he had heard Mr. Nevile Strange leave the house, but had not seen him. Nevile had left at about twenty-past ten or perhaps a little later. He himself had heard nothing during the night. He was up and in the garden when the discovery of Lady Tressilian's body had been made. He was an early riser.
There was a pause.
"Miss Aldin has told us that there was a state of tension in the house. Did you notice this, too?"
"I don't think so. Don't notice things much."
"That's a lie," thought Battle to himself. "You notice a good deal, I should say -more than most."
No, he didn't think Nevile Strange had been short of money in any way. He certainly had not seemed to. But he knew very little about Mr. Strange's affairs.
"How well did you know the second Mrs. Strange?" "I met her here for the first time." Battle played his last card.
"You may know, Mr. Royde, that we've found Mr. Nevile Strange's fingerprints on the weapon. And we've found blood on the sleeve of the coat he wore last night."
He paused. Royde nodded.
"He was telling us," he muttered.
"I'm asking you frankly: Do you think he did it?"
Thomas Royde never liked to be hurried. He waited for a minute - which is a very long time - before he answered: "Don't see why you ask me. Not my business. It's yours. Should say, myself - very unlikely."
"Can you think of anyone who seems to you more likely?"
Thomas shook his head. "Only person I think likely can't possibly have done it. So that's that."
"And who is that?"
But Royde shook his head more decidedly.
"Couldn't possibly say. Only my private opinion."
"It's your duty to assist the police."
"Tell you any facts. This isn't facts. Just an idea. And it's impossible anyway."
"We didn't get much out of him," said Leach when Royde had gone.
Battle agreed.
"No, we didn't. He's got something in his mind - something quite definite. I'd like to know what it is. This is a very peculiar sort of crime, Jim, my boy -"
The telephone rang before Leach could answer. He took up the receiver and spoke. After a minute or two of listening he said "Good," and slammed it down.
"Blood on the coat sleeve is human," he announced.
"Same blood group as Lady T's. Looks as though Nevile Strange is for it -"
Battle had walked over to the window and was looking out with considerable interest.
"A beautiful young man out there," he remarked. "Quite beautiful and a definite wrong 'un, I should say. It's a pity Mr. Latimer - for I feel that that's Mr. Latimer -was over at Easterhead Bay last night. He's the type that would smash in his own grandmother's head if he thought he could get away with it and if he knew he'd make something out of it."
"Well, there wasn't anything in it for him," said Leach. "Lady T's death doesn't benefit him in any way whatever." The telephone bell rang again. "Damn this phone, what's the matter now?"
He went to it.
"Hullo. Oh, it's you, doctor. What? Come round, has she? What? What?"
He turned his head. "Uncle, just come and listen to this."
Battle came over and took the phone. He listened, his face as usual showing no expression. He said to Leach: "Get Nevile Strange, Jim."
When Nevile came in, Battle was just replacing the phone on its hook.
Nevile, looking white and spent, stared curiously at the Scotland Yard superintendent, trying to read the emotion behind the wooden mask.
"Mr. Strange," said Battle. "Do you know anyone who dislikes you very much?" Nevile stared and shook his head.
"Sure?" Battle was impressive. "I mean, sir, someone who does more than dislike you - someone who - frankly - hates your guts?"
Nevile sat bolt upright.
"No. No, certainly not. Nothing of the kind."
"Think, Mr. Strange. Is there no one you've injured in any way -" Nevile flushed.
"There's only one person I can be said to have injured, and she's not the kind who bears rancour. That's my first wife, when I left her for another woman. But I can assure you that she doesn't hate me. She's - she's been an angel."
The Superintendent leaned forward across the table.
"Let me tell you, Mr. Strange, you're a very lucky man. I don't say I liked the case against you -I didn't. But it was a case! It would have stood up all right, and unless the jury happened to have liked your personality, it would have hanged you."
"You speak," said Nevile, "as though all that were past."
